Alumni Athletes
| 2025 | ||
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Edgar Thielens | Cornell University |
| Soccer | Roshan Greene | Washington University |
| Soccer | Sebastian Ballesteros | University of Rochester |
| Volleyball | Nathaniel Black | Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
| Volleyball | Dhruv Prathipati | New York University |
| Fencing | Tanishka Padhye | Stanford University |
| 2024 | ||
| Track & Field | Fred Reed | Occidental College |
| Soccer | Amar Singh | Southwestern University |
| Swimming | Larkin Helman | John Hopkins University |
| Golf | Ross Wright | University of South Carolina - Upstate |
| Track & Field | William Mayer-Brownfeld | Trinity College |
| 2023 | ||
| Lacrosse | Olivia Petrosky | Westminster College |
| Soccer | Ari Reimers | Carnegie Mellon University |
| 2021 | ||
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Alexander Gadin | Washington University in St. Louis |
| Fencing | Mihir Kumashi | Harvard University |
| Fencing (Olympics Team - Chile) | Katina Proestakis | University of Pennsylvania |
| 2020 | ||
| Soccer | Mofe Ariyo | Southwestern University |
| Track & Field | Sebastian Peralta | Carnegie Mellon |
| 2019 | ||
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Melvin Cruz | Trinity University |
| 2018 | ||
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Ashling Devins | Emory University |
| Swimming | Leila El Masri | Claremont Mudd Scripps |
| Fencing (Olympics Team - Egypt) | Mohamed Hamza | Princeton University |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Jackson Meyer | Trinity University |
| Sailing | Kiera O'Reardon | College of Charleston |
| 2017 | ||
| Soccer | Stephanie Halow | Rice University |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Carrie McIntyre | Emory University |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Nicolas Motta | Carnegie Mellon University |
| Soccer | Peter Prentice | Colgate University |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Ximena Reyes Torres | University of Rochester |
| 2016 | ||
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Amanda Gerlach | Trinity University |
| Tennis | Francesca Canjar | Trinity University |
| Rugby | Connor Grace | Notre Dame |
| Soccer | Charlie Meacham | Carnegie Mellon University |
| Track & Field | Catherine Ohrt | Brown University |
| Softball | Joni Grommesh | Babson College |
| 2015 | ||
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Ben Matthews | Trinity University |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Nikita Prasad | University of Houston |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Thor Crux | UTSA |
| Soccer | Conor Hogan | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps |
| 2014 | ||
| Soccer | Michel Farhat | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology |
| 2012 | ||
| Soccer | Christian Manisck | UCLA |
| Soccer | Aziz Saqr | Georgetown University |
| Swimming | Andrea Moreno | Denison University |
| Track & Field | Jonathan Freeman | Case Western |
| 2011 | ||
| Tennis | Emily Bruch | Lehigh University |
| Track & Field | Babette Hohrath | Lehigh University |
| 2010 | ||
| Soccer | Mark Donahue | Drexel University |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Charlotte Peeters | Baylor University |
| 2009 | ||
| Soccer | Georgie Walker | Lehigh University |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Lydia Harmon | Occidental |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Laura Pacifico | SMU |
| 2008 | ||
| Basketball | Sam Harris | Trinity University |
| Fencing | Neely Brandfield-Harvey | Columbia |
| Soccer | Colleen Hogan | Dartmouth |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Catherine Baumgartner | Emory University |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Thomas Cahuzac | Occidental/Columbia |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Sophie Peeters | Rice University |
| 2006 | ||
| Soccer | Islara Rodriguez | University of Houston |
| Soccer | Clinton Smith | Davidson College |
| Track & Field | Patrick Offner | University of Chicago |
| 2004 | ||
| Soccer | Elliot Paller | Cal Tech |
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Malin Fuglesang | Rice University |
| 2003 | ||
| Basketball | Eric Barvi | Emory University |
| Fencing | Richard Spicer | Ohio State |
| Soccer | Stuart Holden | Clemson University |
| 2001 | ||
| Basketball | Bernard Allen | Loyola University Maryland |
| Basketball | Jayce Lewis | Florida International University |
| Crew | Allison White | Georgetown University |
| Track & Field | Garrett Johnson | Savannah College of Art & Design |
| 2000 | ||
| Basketball | Trammel Martin | University of Chicago |
| Track & Field | Alix Banham | Williams |
| Track & Field | Pablo Fernandez | SMU |
| 1998 | ||
| Soccer | Carlos Marchani | Rice University |
| Swimming | Kellie Robbin | University of Texas |
| 1997 | ||
| Diving | Gabi Chereches | Tennessee University |
| Soccer | Jacek Mucha | Washington & Lee |
| Track & Field | Elizabeth Madec | Tulane University |
| 1996 | ||
| Soccer | Arnaud DeBuyl | SMU |
| Tennis | Stephanie Herbert | UC Santa Barbara |
| 1994 | ||
| Basketball | Sonny Bazba | UC San Diego |
| Soccer | Jonathan Crawford | Haverford |
| Tennis | Vesi Ivanova | Rice University |
| 1992 | ||
| Track & Field | Shelby Spangler | Trinity University |
| 1991 | ||
| Cross Country / Track & Field | Alex Gajewski | Rice University |
| 1990 | ||
| Soccer | Luis Martinez | Adelphia |
| 1989 | ||
| Crew | Stacie Spangler | Brown University |
| 1986 | ||
| Basketball | Jeff Dyke | Schreiner |
| 1985 | ||
| Soccer | Eric Holenka | Versailles (France) |
| Soccer | Stephanie Ruz | Houston Baptist |
| Tennis | Tammy Christiansen | SMU |
| Tennis | Kim Gaido | SMU |